|
If you care about the quality and performance of air cleaner or air purifier that
you plan to buy then please read this;
There are almost no UK industry standards against which to measure and judge
air cleaners, so sellers can make claims that are actually quite
dubious. Here are some things to be aware of when buying your air cleaner.
Statistics.
These are banded about
with abandon. They can appear impressive but consider what they actually
mean. For example, an air cleaner might have a claimed efficiency of 99.99%.
But question; 99.99% of what exactly, what size particles, and on what
airflow? It is easy to claim that more or less any air cleaner can have an
almost 100% efficiency given the right size particle challenge and a very
low airflow. Also beware machines that describe themselves as having HEPA
filters. In the filter industry HEPAs come in a variety of grades, which are
testable against any one of several industry standards. It is easy to make a
claim of having a air cleaner with HEPA filtration when test airflow is much
smaller than would be the case for a official test.
Airflow.
Airflow through an air
cleaner means two things. Firstly, it gives rise to ‘air changes’ in a
room. This means, for instance, if a room has a volume of 60m3, then a air
cleaner that has an air flow of 360m3/hr will process the air in the room 6
times (air changes). Generally speaking the higher the airflow the quicker
the unit will filter the air in a room and return it to a clean state when
something happens like an influx of dirty air from an open door. Generally
speaking the more often the air is passed through an air cleaner the cleaner
the air will be maintained. A unit with a HEPA (high efficiency particle
arrestance) filter and a low airflow could in fact be less effective than a
unit with a lower grade of filter and a higher airflow. Air flow also gives
rise to sound. Forced air movement through an air cleaner is impossible
without generating sound. The more air you move, the more noise you get.
The performance of plasma and ozone based systems cannot be easily
compared on the basis of air flow. Certainly it is a mistake to compare the
airflow of a plasma or ozone system with a filter based system.
Performance
A system based on good quality filters will
inevitably be better at particulate removal that systems based on ozone or
UV, although generally they will be more expensive. Systems based on ozone
and/or UV are generally designed to provide air which is free of viruses,
smells, VOCs, bacteria, spores, chemicals etc. and will do this with
variable degrees of effectiveness. The important thing here is to choose and
use an air purifier that is suited to the size of room. Too large an air
purifier and there is a risk of ozone build up - too small and the unit will
struggle to be effective. Systems based on good filters will be more
expensive, as they tend to be more robustly constructed and have better
fans.
Quality
The old adage you pay for what you get is as true for
air cleaners as for any other item. More expensive air cleaners, will
typically have better and larger filters (hold more dust), will have better
quality fans (better bearings, heavier motors etc.) have stronger bodywork
parts. In other words they are designed to do a job and last.
Features
Often when you look at the various options on cleaners
you will see a dazzling array of features and air cleaning 'hype' words.
Sometimes the features are crammed into the air cleaner just to get ticks in
potential buyer's 'mental check boxes', and are designed with economy in
mind rather than performance. Lots of impressive filter stages and features
may impress at first glance but each stage may be so under engineered so as
to be useless.
Ozone
Some companies will go out of their way to give
air purifiers that produce ozone a bad press. This is not a black and white
issue, and buyers should understand some background to these potentially
misleading assertions. Ozone is a powerful oxidising gas, which can be
produced in harmful high concentration by ozone generators. These devices
make ozone using electrical discharge and can easily generate ozone levels
well above the laid down safety guidelines. Units that make ozone by ultra violet light
based purification usually produce
ozone at safe low concentration and as part of a 'photoplasma' which also
contains oxygen singlets O, and hydroxyls OH. Provided that these type of
purifiers are used in accordance with the manufacturers recommendations,
the ozone concentration in the enclosed area will always be below 0.04ppm,
which is far lower than the safety thresholds set by the Health and Safety
Executive.
Our Descriptions
In our descriptions of the various air cleaners
and purifiers that are offered on this website, we have reproduced, where
appropriate, the claims of the makers of the various machines. Where claims
appear 'over the top' to us as air purity specialists, we either omit to
reproduce them here or tone them down a bit. (eg. if claimed to be a HEPA,
we would probably say a high efficiency filter). The claims that are stated
here are believed to be credible, however, not are not proven in any
industry wide benchmark test standard. It is this approach that makes us
distinctly different from other sellers of this type of equipment.
|